End of an Era: Galveston's 1817 Steak & Seafare and Li'l Buffalo Grille to Close

Two beloved Galveston restaurants, 1817 Steak & Seafare and Li'l Buffalo Grille, will close their doors on January 5 as their owners step away from the restaurant business.

Jaiden Quitzon

By 

Jaiden Quitzon

Published 

Jan 4, 2025

End of an Era: Galveston's 1817 Steak & Seafare and Li'l Buffalo Grille to Close

Owners Jessica and John McAleer made the emotional statement on social media Thursday evening, citing a painful decision to exit the restaurant industry.

"After much careful consideration, we have made the difficult decision to step away from the restaurant business," the McAleers wrote in their statement.

1817 Steak & Seafare, which opened in June 2024 in Galveston's Evia district, immediately became well-known for its sommelier-curated wine list, fresh raw oysters, and top steaks. Meanwhile, the casual Li'l Buffalo Grille became a local favorite for its hearty breakfasts and soothing lunch options such as soups and salads.

The McAleers invited fans to visit for one last supper before shutting, and they announced that Dennis Byrd of the Island Famous Hospitality Group will shortly take over the facility. While details of Byrd's plans remain unknown, the McAleers have indicated their support for the move.

The closing comes after a difficult year for Galveston's eating scene, which witnessed the closure of other famous establishments such as Tortuga Mexican Kitchen, Texas Pit Stop BBQ, and health-focused cafe Eatcetera. Fans of 1817 Steak and Li'l Buffalo Grille voiced their disappointment online, praising the restaurants' quality and wishing the owners the best.

As the McAleers depart, Galveston focuses on the legacy of these beloved restaurants and looks forward to the next chapter in their old locations.

Related Posts